Return to the archive index

Here's the big CPU power comparison chart

From: Doug Sutherland <>
Date: Fri, 18 May 2001 00:24:56 +0000

Continuing on with the power comparisons, here's a chart with power 
consumption for a bunch of Geode (MMX), Pentium (various), and the
ELAN 520 and MachZ boards with and without audio. If DSP Design is 
right about DP400 it might be the lowest power multimedia solution 
out there (x86 compatible) consuming 3.2 watts at 166Mhz . Lippert 
Cool Runner looks good at 4.0 watts 200Mhz. Advantech is midrange 
at 7.5 watts 200Mhz, but is still better than a lot of boards with
no audio onboard. On the high end Cell Computing PlugNRun is a 
heavy power consumer (25 watts!). I don't know what Lanner is doing 
but their numbers are very high for Geode based boards relative to 
the competition. According to the specs I have gathered below the 
TP400 and Cool Runner are pretty steep power competition to even 
the AMD ELAN 520 based boards and MZ104. The power specs on both 
ELAN 520 and MachZ are quite disappointing. Take all this with a 
grain of salt because we don't know who is using conservative or 
optimistic power specifications. Wish I could try battery tests
on all of them ...

-----------------------------------------------------------------
The following CPU boards all have audio:

Model              Clock   Supply     Power   CPU V   CPU  
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Advantech
PCM-5822           200Mhz  5v 1.50A   7.5 watts  2.2v Geode GXM-200
PCM-5820/E         200Mhz  5v 1.50A   7.5 watts  2.2v Geode GXM-200
PCM-5820           233Mhz  5v 3.00A  15.0 watts  2.9v Geode GXM-233
PCM-5820 Rev A104+ 233Mhz  5v 1.90A   9.5 watts  2.9v Geode GXM-233

Lippert 
Cool Runner        200Mhz  5v 0.80A   4.0 watts  2.2v Geode GXI
Cool Runner        300Mhz  5v 1.10A   5.5 watts  2.0v Geode GXI         
Cool Runner        166Mhz  5v 1.20A   6.0 watts  2.2v Geode GLXV
Cool Runner        233Mhz  5v 1.50A   7.5 watts  1.6v Geode GXLV

DSP Design 
TP400              166Mhz  5v 0.64A   3.2 watts  ?    Geode ?    
TP400              300Mhz  5v 1.00A   5.0 watts  ?    Geode ? 

Lanner 
EM-350             233Mhz  5v 3.19A  16.0 watts  ?    Geode GXm
PC-2553            233Mhz  5v 2.52A  12.6 watts  ?    Geode GXm

Jumptec
ETX-MGX            266Mhz  5v 1.10A   5.5 watts  ?    Geode GX1 
ETX-E520           133Mhz  5v 1.20A   6.0 watts  ?    ELAN SC520
EXT-P1             266Mhz  5v 1.16A   5.8 watts  ?    Pentium MMX
ETX-P3             400Mhz  5v 4.00A  20.0 watts  ?    Pentium III

-----------------------------------------------------------------
The following CPU boards do not have audio:

Model              Clock   Supply     Power   CPU V   CPU  
-----------------------------------------------------------------

Jumptec
PC/104 520          66Mhz  5v 0.65A   3.3 watts  ?    ELAN SC520
PC/104 520         100Mhz  5v 1.00A   5.0 watts  ?    ELAN SC520
PC/104 520         133Mhz  5v 1.05A   5.3 watts  ?    ELAN SC520
PC/104 686         266Mhz  5v 1.60A   8.0 watts  ?    AMD K6
MOPS LCD6          266Mhz  5v 1.80A   9.0 watts  ?    Pentium MMX

Tri-M Systems
MZ104               33Mhz  5v 0.58A   2.9 watts  ?    MachZ
MZ104               66Mhz  5v 0.64A   3.2 watts  ?    MachZ
MZ104              100Mhz  5v 0.68A   3.4 watts  ?    MachZ
MZ104              133Mhz  5v 0.74A   3.7 watts  ?    MachZ
(*) - MZ104 has no audio, video, or ethernet. Specs on power
      for MZ104+ and ICC-MZ104 are still pending.

Cell Computing
PlugNRun PR5/166   166Mhz  5v 1.36A   6.8 watts  ?    Pentium MMX
PlugNRun PR5/233   233Mhz  5v 2.14A  10.7 watts  ?    Pentium MMX
PlugNRun PR5/266   266Mhz  5v 2.12A  10.6 watts  ?    Pentium MMX
PlugNRun PR6/333   333Mhz  5v 2.82A  14.1 watts  ?    Pentium II
PlugNRun PR7/400   400Mhz  5v 3.04A  15.2 watts  ?    Celeron 400
PlugNRun PR7/500   500Mhz  5v 3.34A  16.7 watts  ?    Pentium III
(*) - The power listed above is just the PNR module without 
      NetCard which itself lists at 10.7 watts!

--
Subscription/unsubscription/info requests: send e-mail with subject of
"subscribe", "unsubscribe", or "info" to 
Wear-Hard Mailing List Archive (searchable): http://wearables.blu.org
please, Please, *PLEASE* don't subscribe through a forward/false domain

+Previous Message in Thread | Next Message in Thread

From Wear-Hard Mailing list Archive (WH)
Maintained by R. Paul McCarty

Archive created with babymail