Return to the archive index

Xybernaut sues for defamation

From: Vito Miliano <>
Date: Sun, 3 Mar 2002 14:25:19 -0500

This is interesting, and also very unfortunate.  Because of this, I
will not purchase one or more Pomas for the work I'm doing.  I will
likely never purchase a Xybernaut product at all, and I ask you all to
consider this situation.

http://www.wired.com/news/business/0,1367,50548,00.html

"Dan Whatley has a few words of advice for those inclined to flame the
CEO of an unpopular company.

Whatley learned last week he had lost a $450,000 defamation lawsuit
for statements he had made about a company called Xybernaut on an
Internet message board.  He said he didn't even know the suit
existed."

Xybernaut sued him for defamation over message board postings where he
criticizes the CEO and vice-chairman of Xybernaut.  From the article:

'"I have been dealing with the Newmans and XYBR and they are the most
incompetent management I have ever seen," the suit quoted Whatley
writing in one post, under his handle, dan7. "If Steve Newman was not
a relative his job would consist of ... 'Would you like fries with
that?'"

Whatley also called the Newmans "liars" in several different posts.'

These types of lawsuits are called SLAPPs, Strategic Lawsuits Against
Public Participation; essentially corporate quelling of free speech.
The claims, to qualify as defamation, have to appear as statements of
fact, not just as opinion.  Dan Whatley likely lost simply because he
didn't appear in court, and I believe the claims that he was never
notified of the suit to begin with:

In May of 2001, I was sued by American Express, and lost.  I found out
about it in January of 2002.  When suits are delivered to your door,
at least in New York State, they're hand-delivered by courier to *your
address*.  The courier certifies that it was delivered, and that's
good enough.  If you're not home, and it blows away because it was
just tossed on your front porch, tough luck; the only person you can
sue is the courier.  If you don't even live at the address they
decided to deliver to, also tough luck.  Sue the courier, because you
can't take back the lawsuit that you lost eight months ago.

If Xybernaut and its management are petty and invective enough to
frivolously sue over message board posts that they simply don't like,
then I will not do business with them.  SLAPPs are unacceptable
corporate practices in my book.  I urge you all to reconsider your
relationships with them as well.

Thanks,
--Vito

--
Subscription/unsubscription/info requests: send e-mail with subject of
"subscribe", "unsubscribe", or "info" to 
Wear-Hard Mailing List Archive (searchable): http://wearables.blu.org
Please, *PLEASE* don't subscribe through a forward/expander/false domain

+Previous Message in Thread | Next Message in Thread

From Wear-Hard Mailing list Archive (WH)
Maintained by R. Paul McCarty

Archive created with babymail